Meat Stock and GAPS: Not Bone Broth!
Meat Stock is the backbone of the GAPS diet. Whether you start on Intro or Full GAPS, Dr. Natasha recommends you consume meat stock for an average of 1 year before switching to bone broth. Why? Meat stock is less digestively complex than bone broth and contains higher levels of collagen, gelatin, and amino acids that play a role in your ability to heal yourself.
Meat Stock vs. Bone Broth
Quite literally, meat stock is the glue that seals up your intestinal lining. It is so powerful that it can decapitate overgrown yeast tendrils, or yeasts that have overgrown to the point of growing ‘arms’ that break through your intestinal wall and into your body cavity. Specialists have found yeast tendrils up to 4 feet long in people. Wow! So drinking meat stock decapitates this tendril growth and nips it in the bud.
To get the full benefits of meat stock, Dr. Natasha recommends that you, as an adult, need to drink 5 cups per day, children need 3 cups, and infants need 1/2 of a cup. Generally if you are eating two quarts of soup per day, you are getting about 4 cups of meat stock. Drinking one more cup in the morning will get you to the optimal level of stock consumption! Hint: there are 4 cups in one quart. If you are not eating soup, drink 1-2 cups of stock with each meal.
Bone broth, on the other had, has high levels of glutamic acid, a complicated-to-digest compound that is one molecule different from MonoSodium Glutamate, or MSG. When your digestive system is not robust enough, it breaks down this glutamic acid into MSG, an excitotoxin. MSG overstimulates your neurons in the frontal, thinking part of your brain. It virtually fries it. No thank you!
So for the first year of GAPS, stick to meat stock and drink 5 cups per day! When more healing has taken place, you can graduate to bone broth for its gut maintenance qualities and high mineral content.
How to make meat stock:
Source + choose your meat cuts:
- Chicken:
- whole chicken
- necks
- backs
- feet
- thighs
- drumsticks
- whole legs
- Beef or Bison
- shanks
- oxtail
- chuck roast (bone- in)
- cross rib roast (bone-in)
- knuckle bones
- marrow bones
- neck bones
- short ribs
- hooves
- joint bones
- Pork
- shoulder roast (bone-in)
- loin
- ribs
- neck bones
- ham hocks (fresh, not smoked)
- trotters
- feet
- Lamb
- shanks
- riblets
- feet
- rib rack
- shoulder (bone-in)
- Duck
- whole duck
- feet
- necks
- backs
- Rabbit
- whole rabbit
- Fish
- whole fish
- heads
- fins
…or any other cut of meat attached to bone with connective tissue. But you get the idea!
***The most quality meat stock has a combination of meat attached to bone, joints, feet, and marrow bones in it.***
You technically can cook different animal meats together, just try to keep them in the same family. For instance, keep the poultry together, the fish together, the pork together, and the red meat together to accomplish appropriate cook times.
To start, for any animal, place your cuts of meat in a stockpot. Try to cover the bottom surface with meat as much as possible, and then fill your pot with filtered water until it covers your meat by one inch. Add salt to taste. Start with about 2 tsp of sea salt per quart and work up from there. You may add in fresh herbs and vegetables of your choosing, but you do not have to.
Bring to a boil and simmer. This is where the cooking times differ.
Cooking Times for Meat Stock:
Fish: Simmer for 30 minutes to 1 hour
Poultry: 1.5-2 hours
Pork: 3 hours
Red Meat: 3-4 hours
Skim the ‘scum,’ a bubbly foam, off the top of your stock when it starts to boil. Once cooked, take out meat with tongs and allow time to cool. Then strip the meat off the bones with your hands into a separate container, placing gooey connective tissue, extra fat, and bone marrow back into your stock. Blend the connective tissue and fat back into your stock with an immersion blender. Then transfer it into mason jars. Allow your jars of stock to cool to room temperature before putting them into your fridge.
Congratulations! Now you have stock for soups, casual drinking, and new recipes. This meat stock actively seals up your intestinal lining. You can add extra animal fat, sauerkraut juice, and a garlic clove for a fun morning drink. Your body says thank you and Hooray!
Meat Stock Instructional Video
If you want a step-by-step video of EXACTLY how to make meat stock, I made an Instructional Video for you. It has been reviewed + approved for accuracy by Dr. Natasha’s son. This meat stock video shows you how to make meat stock for GAPS Intro, how to make meat stock for full GAPS (including how to not have any ‘boiled meat’ leftover), and explains exactly why you need to care & be super diligent about your intake. There is an instructional resource guide attached for exactly how to source your meat, the GAPS approved cooking equipment you’ll need, & more. For additional info about this, you can click here.
GAPS Certified Instructional Videos so You can Transform Your Life
It took me: 3.5 years on GAPS, a lyme diagnosis, record-breaking amounts of pesticides in my body, an incredible amount of heavy metals, a GAPS practitioner certification, and 8 months working intensely with one of the top GAPS Practitioners in the world before I figured out how to do GAPS right + truly started healing myself. I don’t think it should take that much time, suffering, or study for you.
That’s why I created the GAPS Certified Instructional Videos approved by Dr. Natasha’s Son to completely change the way people go on GAPS forever. You’re in the right place if you want to See the Videos.
Thank you for clear instructions. The 3
books and articles, Even the naturopath I got a recipe from are unclear and make mistakes!
I really hope I don’t have to do the intro for too long. Am on day two.
I hope you don’t have to be on Intro long either, but even if you have to, it’s okay! Just remember you are a beautiful human worth all of the healing you can give yourself! Feel free to shoot me an email if you have questions about the the stock. Happy soup making!
Thanks for making this simple to understand! I’ve nailed whole chicken meat stock but no other kinds.. this helps to simplify it. What have you found to be the most affordable way to make stock besides whole chicken? How much would you say you spend a week on your meat cuts for stock? I didn’t realize I needed a full 5 cups of stock.. whoops. Have been doing about 3+. We have mostly been using whole chickens for stock- we FLY through the broth and have trouble keeping up with eating all of the chicken… I need to find less-meaty ways of making broth. Thanks for your help!
So much yes! Too all of this! My simple, one word answer- FEET! lots and lots of feet. I can get organic pigs feet from my local butcher for less than 2$/lb. Chicken feet are even cheaper. And it really depends on which cuts I use for meat stock as far as cost goes… If I’m using all feet, it probably costs like $30. If I’m using an entire pig leg, it costs over $100. Shows you the extremes it can go to!
Hello there.
What do you do with all that fat that is swimming on top of beef stock soup when soup is already cooked. Is it safe to consume all that fat floating on the soup, or do you remove it. Becasue that is a lot of greas.
Best wishes and regards
Jure
Hey Jure, I drink all the fat. Dr. Natasha says that the more pastured animal fat she sees people eat, the quicker they heal. The only contraindication would be if you have a hard time digesting fat, which is pretty common when people first start GAPS. In that case, I recommend people make + drink beet kvass. Here is the recipe link if you want to know how to make it.
https://www.laurenmeadowsweet.com/beet-kvass-recipe-the-ultimate-fat-digestion-aid/
how long does a 4 year old keep taking meat stock and how much?
Is there a time we stop or are we always going to need meat stock?
We are on stage 5/6 now when do we consider meat broth?
Thank you
I would say at least 2 cups for a 4 year old. But everyone is different. In theory, you can drink as much meat stock as you can tolerate. Bone broth is introduced 1 year into the GAPS protocol.
I would like to try the Meat Stock for Gut healing.. A few months back I tried to do a bone broth but I had a nervous type reaction when I tried eating.. maybe Mast Cells.. I wonder if the Meat Stock would be better on the stomach? I definitely would like to try it. Has anyone had any issues?
It’s possible it may have been related to the L- glutamine in the bone broth, which is very molecularly similar to MSG {a neurotoxin}. If you have digestive problems your body can interpret them as the same thing. And If you’re curious about meat stock, I’d give it a try! It has a very different chemical structure from bone broth.
Hi Lauren! Wow this article was very insightful and interesting. I just started the GAPS protocol and have been on bone broth for the last two weeks, seemingly having no issues with it. My ears are perked now that I’m hearing it’s a major no-go.
I’m curious if you’re open to sharing the scientific journal references or studies that you found the idea that glutamic acid turns to MSG?
Looking forward to hearing from you!
– Isa
Hey Isa,
glutamic acid does NOT turn into msg. It just has a very similar molecular structure. I learned this from the official GAPS chef, Monica Corrado. If you want to check her out, her site is simplybeingwell.com. 🙂